The 5 Best Flooring Options for a New Custom Home

When you’re building a custom home, few choices are more important than the flooring. From hardwood and tile to vinyl and carpet, different types of flooring bring a unique look and feel to a room. Today, there are many amazing flooring options available to give you the function and style you want while also staying within your budget.

Because flooring is difficult to change up, it’s a commitment that can last for years if not decades. So, as you think about flooring options, don’t focus solely on price. You want to choose flooring that will endure foot traffic well over the years, particularly if you have children or pets. You also want to select materials and colors that enhance your home and blend with its overall décor. And not least of all, you want to be comfortable with the maintenance requirements of any flooring you install.

In this blog, we’ll take a look at the pros and cons of our favorite flooring picks for “new builds near me.”

Luxury vinyl plank flooring

Hardwood Flooring

There’s a reason hardwood has been the flooring of choice for centuries: it excels at providing both durability and beauty. There are as many types of hardwood as there are trees, each with its own distinctive color and graining.

Today, manufacturers produce both solid hardwood and engineered hardwood flooring. Engineered hardwood offers a lower price point and can easily be mistaken for solid hardwood. It is constructed by bonding a thin layer of hardwood to a plywood core. For this reason, it can’t be refinished as often as solid hardwood flooring but can still last up to 30 years or more with proper maintenance.

Benefits of Hardwood Floors

In addition to the advantages mentioned above, hardwood creates a rich, warm look that is very desirable throughout the home, from the kitchen to the bedroom. It comes in a wide variety of finishes and many species of hardwood are available in a range of plank sizes, resulting in lots of options when it comes to style and pattern. And while hardwood may be expensive, it can easily be refinished multiple times to eliminate dents, dings and stains. Engineered hardwood is thinner and cannot be refinished as many times.

Drawbacks of Hardwood Floors

The primary downside of hardwood flooring is cost. It’s labor-intensive to manufacture and install, so the price can top $10 per square foot for more exotic tree species. It is prone to scratches and can also be easily damaged by water, making it susceptible to leaking dishwashers and broken pipes.

Installation of maple hardwood flooring

Vinyl Flooring

If you love the look of hardwood or stone tile but the real thing is beyond your budget, vinyl does an excellent job of mimicking the appearance of these materials. Today’s luxury vinyl comes in both tiles and planks and offers a long list of advantages. It’s an ideal choice for high-traffic areas such as kitchens and bathrooms, and homes with kids and pets.

Benefits of Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl plank flooring has emerged as a popular option in the flooring market because homeowners love its durability and modern, sleek style. It comes in a huge range of style and color combinations, all of which are water-resistant and easy to clean. Vinyl can be the perfect solution for areas with moisture problems such as bathrooms, entryways and basements. One of the features of luxury vinyl is a cork or foam underlay that makes it feel softer underfoot – an especially nice benefit when vinyl is installed over a concrete subfloor. Its underlay also gives luxury vinyl better sound-absorbing properties.

Drawbacks of Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl doesn’t have the best return on investment for homes for sale in Cheyenne compared to hardwood and tile, primarily because it doesn’t provide quite the same high-end appearance.

luxury vinyl plank flooring in Cheyenne custom home
Luxury vinyl plank flooring

Tile & Stone Flooring

When it comes to sheer durability, nothing beats tile and stone. They also offer the classic beauty that today’s homeowners are looking for. Choose from materials that include ceramic, glass, porcelain and many natural stones including marble, slate and granite. Installing tile is labor-intensive and takes a great deal of skill.

Benefits of Tile & Stone Flooring

While these materials have long been installed in kitchens and bathrooms because they are water-resistant, tile and stone are beautiful enough to be used in any room. They come in nearly any color, style and texture you can imagine; wood-look plank tile has become especially popular in recent years. If you want to cut down on dust and allergens in your indoor environment, tile is an ideal flooring selection. Most tile has a lower cost per square foot than hardwood but more than luxury vinyl.

Drawbacks of Tile & Stone Flooring

Certain types of stone are porous and require regular sealing to prevent damage and staining. And while tile and stone are exceptionally durable, they may crack and chip if heavy objects are dropped.

stone and tile flooring in master bathroom
Stone and tile flooring in master bathroom


While hardwood and vinyl are popular for “new builds near me,” carpet remains an important flooring material in Wyoming homes because it provides warmth and coziness. On cold winter mornings, nothing beats the comfort of soft carpet underfoot.

Benefits of Carpet

In addition to its insulative properties, carpet effectively reduces noise within the home. Its softer acoustics are ideal for bedrooms, hallways and other areas where a quiet environment is desirable. For households with young children and seniors, carpet offers a reduced risk of slips and falls compared to hard flooring surfaces. It’s also on the lower end when it comes to cost.

Drawbacks of Carpet

Low-quality carpet may not wear well. While there are stain-resistant options, carpet is prone to stains and requires more maintenance to keep it looking nice. Clean up spills quickly and vacuum regularly to keep dirt from building up in the fibers. Cover high-traffic areas with rugs or mats to extend the life of carpet. An annual professional cleaning is recommended to keep carpet looking its best. And finally, do not install carpet in areas that are moisture-prone such as kitchens and bathrooms.

Upgraded carpet by Dwellings

Ready to Shop ‘New Builds Near Me’?

With a custom home, you enjoy the freedom to incorporate several types of flooring throughout the house, depending on your style preferences and how you will use each space. And if you choose a semi-custom Cheyenne home for sale built by Gateway, you may still be able to choose the flooring, depending on the stage of construction. If you’re ready to discuss your dream home, call the Gateway team today at (307) 632-8950 or complete our online contact request form.

Not yet ready to shop homes for sale in Cheyenne, WY? Stay connected with Gateway by following us on our socials, including FacebookInstagramX and LinkedIn. You can also check out the latest videos on our YouTube channel!


Get $1,000 OFF a Gateway Home!

Sign up for our email list and we’ll send you our latest updates and new listings, along with serious savings on your next home purchase.